Historically, university students are the site of political movements that have fundamentally changed society and politics. To name but a few, in 1965, 250 students protested outside Edinburghâs American embassy against the Vietnam War. In 1989, students demanding democracy and freedom of the press and of speech in Tiananmen Square, Beijing were massacred by the government. Worldwide, universities themselves have been locations of teach-ins and sit-ins during such protests, especially in the 60âs. Â
Issues of the present day continue to politicise students up and down the UK. In 2014, Laura Coryton began the campaign against tampon tax while she was a student at Goldsmithâs University. The University of Leicester offers a course on Activism and Protest in the Information Age, which covers topics such as the US Black Lives Matter movement and the Hong Kong Umbrella Movement. Which? University also has a list of the top universities for a political scene, for students who prioritise political activism in their criteria when choosing universities.
Yet there is heavy backlash against politics within universities, with some claiming that the campaigns at university are shielded from the realities of the world. They claim that university debates and student union elections are too sensitive to political correctness and that ânoisy zealotsâ drown out the silent majority. They also say that what students campaign for has no real impact in the wider scheme of things.
For example, in 2015, Brendan OâNeill was invited to Oxford University to debate with Tim Stanley – both journalists – Â on the motion that âThis House Believes Britainâs Abortion Culture Hurts Us Allâ. It was boycotted by Oxford feminists on the basis that two men shouldnât debate such a sensitive female issue. Both OâNeill and Stanley responded to the cancelled debates by writing articles that highlighted how the debate was not about abortion rights – which arguably is a womanâs issue more than a manâs – but about the culture surrounding it. Both lashed out at the students who were quick to judge, prevented a genuine discussion from happening, and ultimately put free speech under assault. (Links to their articles are below.)
Taking this example, I agree that (Leftist) students can become authoritarian – a few trigger words and they have the backing of the majority who would previously have been un-politicised, who stand by them because âsmashing capitalismâ and âdismantling the patriarchyâ is what theyâre told to do on Instagram. Students need to be careful – be noisy enough to be heard, but donât shut down the opinions of others.
Universities are an extremely easy place to get everyone on your side. Youâll probably never meet so many people who have the same views as you in one place. This power needs to be used respectably.
This said, itâs impossible to draw the line between right and wrong, what is free speech and what is hate speech, how politically correct is too politically correct. Yet I donât believe that students should be told to forget that they have an impact on this world. Students have SO MUCH power. The power to sway elections (if they pay attention to them), the power to fight for womenâs rights (and support the men who do as well), and the power to empower other students. But remember that research and empathy is key. Grounded arguments begin with reliable facts and that result in stronger views â shouting assumptions will leave a messy trail that is difficult to follow.
Sources:
https://le.ac.uk/modules/ms3022
https://campus.one.org/stories/4-times-student-activists-changed-world/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student_activism#United_Kingdom
https://www.theguardian.com/education/2010/jul/06/jo-swinson-student-politics-career
Tim Stanleyâs response:https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/11239437/Oxford-students-shut-down-abortion-debate.-Free-speech-is-under-assault-on-campus.html
Brendon OâNeillâs http://www.spiked-online.com/newsite/article/why-i-am-pro-choice/16221#.Wr2BcC7wapo
Â
Images sources:
https://www.dissentmagazine.org/wp-content/files_mf/1505235993ISSERMANPBSS11961ENDTHEWAR666.jpg
https://giphy.com/gifs/vday-11b8CC4gstDAT6
https://giphy.com/gifs/funny-animation-cute-xT9IgpxorXdkhoQle8
https://giphy.com/gifs/drunkhistory-comedy-central-XKjsHBNARuzRVxXJbd