Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo

Date or Ditch? Mr Darcy vs. Gatsby

This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at Durham chapter.

Whilst most girls fantasize about their favourite celebrity or perhaps the latest Oscar winner, I myself see no qualms in imagining what life would be like with some of those well-known names from between the pages. You see the benefit of a literary character is that you can imagine them however you like, (i.e. as jaw-droppingly gorgeous as you like). But the question is, in an ideal world and with all this perfection at my disposal, how would I choose between the dreamy Darcy and charming Gatsby?

So letā€™s start with Mr Darcy. Heā€™s good looking, mysterious, wonderfully rich and great on horseback; I imagine most people would be more than willing to just go ahead and marry the man, but is that all there is to him? I canā€™t help feeling as though the famous novel wasnā€™t entitled Pride and PrejudiceĀ for nothingā€¦

Okay so heā€™s a bit of a snob, but isnā€™t that just another word for fabulously wealthy? Call me shallow, but I think I could put up with a little bit of ā€˜prideā€™ if it meant I could show someone a picture of Pemberley and say, ā€˜Yeah, thatā€™s my houseā€™.

And I mean letā€™s consider Gatsby in this: heā€™s got heaps of cash, and because he didnā€™t inherit it along with an in-built air of haughtiness like Darcy did, you canā€™t deny there had to be some dodgy dealings involved. Plus his success was all in the name of this one girl he hadnā€™t seen for yearsā€¦ isnā€™t that a little creepy?

Oh and speaking from the benefit of hindsight, I definitely wouldnā€™t want a share of all that ā€˜fast cashā€™ with an economic disaster looming on the horizon.

But all money-matters aside, could I deal with the ā€˜prejudiceā€™ of Darcyā€™s breed? As a mere commoner of no significant birth right or great fortune, Iā€™d be instantly shunned by almost his whole social circle. And getting along with your boyfriendā€™s friendsā€¦ even more so his familyā€¦ is pretty important isnā€™t it?

See you wouldnā€™t have this problem with Gatsby. He was a lowly peasant once too, and itā€™s the roaring twenties! Anything goes.

Admittedly, however, this ā€˜anything goesā€™ notion has been known to be taken a tad too far by Mr Gatsby. The relentless parties would surely prove too much for anyone after a while. What if I just want a nice quiet night in? Without showgirls running around and drunken strangers getting off in the garden! I think Iā€™d rather sip tea from a gold-plated tea cup, whilst gazing contently through the window at the beautiful gardens at Pemberley. That sounds more like it.

The truth is Iā€™m a country gal at heart. A gallop through the fields and meadows sounds like a hell of an afternoon, whereas the hustle and bustle of a booming New York City just seems a bit too much. However I must admit, a ride in Gatsbyā€™s car would be a treat wouldnā€™t it? Just give me some red lipstick and a pair of sunglasses and Iā€™m there.

Living in a slightly more liberal society than capitalist 18th century Britain is also quite appealing, and I totally understand why you might decide to ditch Darcy for this simple reason.

Nevertheless, getting involved with Gatsby just seems like a recipe for troubleā€¦ I donā€™t want to end up in an obsessive relationship, and I certainly donā€™t want to venture into those darker corners of the roaring twenties.

And so after much thought, and regardless of his being dubbed Gatsby the ā€˜Greatā€™, Iā€™m afraid I choose Darcy.Ā 

I am currently in my final year of studying English Literature at Durham University, England. I am hoping to become a journalist in the future, but in the mean time, I enjoy cheerleading, fashion and travelling, and of course, being the editor of Durham's Her Campus!