Summertime means a lot of things, but most importantly it means it’s finally hot enough outside to eat ice cream every day. Arguably the best brand in ice cream history, Ben & Jerry’s has become famous for coming up with ultra-creative flavors – all of which we would happily consume. While all of us have a different favorite pint that we could easily down in one sitting, we’ve decided to rank every flavor currently available. Here’s what we’ve decided.
46. Vanilla Toffee Bar Crunch
Let’s be real: This one is pretty simple. They could have gone a little further.
45. Cherry Garcia
Too. Many. Cherries.
44. Coffee, Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz
There are literally two other flavors exactly like this.
43. Vanilla
…Really?
42. Coffee Caramel Buzz
See #44.
41. Pistachio Pistachio
Just…no.
40. Chunky Monkey
This one’s good, but it’s not very original.
39. Save Our Swirled
The love child of raspberry sorbet and Rocky Road. Meh.
38. Triple Caramel Chunk
Isn’t this basically the same as the other caramel vanilla one?!
37. Peanut Butter Cup
Before you hate us for putting anything with peanut butter so low on the list, you should know that there are at least THREE other peanut butter B&J flavors that are way better than this basic one.
36. Blondie Ambition
This would be better if every bite didn’t taste like biting into a sugar cube.
35. Karamel Sutra
This would have been higher on the list if weren’t yet another caramel flavor.
34. Vanilla Caramel Fudge
Someone needs to call these guys and tell them that they’re making too many caramel flavors.
33. New York Super Fudge Chunk
This one is good…but can’t we switch out the nuts for some cookie dough or something?
32. Peanut Butter Half Baked
WHY WAS THIS A LIMITED EDITION???
31. Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch
More coffee? Nah.
30. Salted Caramel
…More caramel.
29. Spectacular Speculoos
This newbie is amazing, but it’s high up for being *another* caramel flavor. Sorry.
28. Peanut Buttah
All right, from here on out, the decisions were just impossible to make.
27. A Swirled of a Difference
Every PB&J lover’s dream come true.
26. Chocolate Fudge Brownie
AKA: What you eat when you’re on your period.
25. What a Cluster
Peanut butter ice cream. Yes all around.
24. Strawberry Cheesecake
Bonus points for originality in the “thick graham cracker swirl.”
23. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
This one is just a classic.
22. Boston Cream Pie
*Doesn’t know what Boston Cream Pie even is*
*Inhales this entire pint regardless*
21. Hazed & Confused
Also known as THE NUTELLA FLAVOR.
20. Chocolate Peppermint Crunch
A great twist on mint chocolate chip ice cream.
19. That’s My Jam
This is the better version of that other raspberry and chocolate one.
18. Peanut Butter World
There are no words to describe this perfection.
17. Chocolate Therapy
Has been proven to be just as good as actual therapy.
16. Chubby Hubby
Say it with me now: Peanut butter AND pretzels.
15. Brewed to Matter
See, THIS is how you do a coffee ice cream. Throw some brownie batter in there.
14. Boom Chocolatta
This new flavor is literally sold out everywhere we go, so it must be incredible.
13. Peanut Butter Fudge
We will eat anything that includes a “peanut butter fudge core.”
12. Cheesecake Brownie
So simple and so perfect.
11. Cinnamon Buns
Because you can eat it for breakfast. Right??
10. Mint Chocolate Cookie
Like Mint Chocolate Chip…but with Oreos.
9. Red Velvet Cake
No words needed.
8. S’mores
We’d take a pint of this over a real s’more any day.
7. Cake Batter
Omg omg omg omg omg omg.
6. Banana Split
Instead of having to go out and find a place that actually still serves a banana split, stock your fridge with this perfection.
5. Everything But The…
All of our favorite flavors in one pint? Sign us up.
4. Phish Food
A staple Ben & Jerry’s flavor, this one has gotten us through so many midterms and heartbreaks.
3. Milk & Cookies
Mouth. Watering.
2. The Tonight Dough
This is #2 partially because of how amazing it is and partially because it has bae’s face on the container. Either way, it’s deserving.
1. Half Baked
The one you’ve all been waiting for… The flavor of all flavors, the foodgasm of all foodgasms, Half Baked is our eternal favorite.