The newest debate between my friends and I is what makes an album good. What is the difference between a good album and a great album? We all had different opinions, but for me, a great album isn’t just one you really like. It has to be perfect. Every song has to be so good you want to listen to it every time it comes on. They also have to be in an order that tells the artist’s story from beginning to end. But, that is not all. The last and probably hardest step: the album has to have made an impact on your life in some way. The greatest albums, just like television shows, books and movies, make you think about them for weeks after. While discussing this, I realized I don’t have any albums I would consider to be completely perfect, but here are some that are pretty close.
“don’t smile at me” by Billie Eilish
We are off to a bad start because this technically isn’t even an album, but an EP. Which is the only reason this cannot be considered S tier. Even so, this is Billie’s best work. Every one of these nine songs is perfection. And, as always, her voice sounds absolutely amazing. I can’t even tell you which songs are my favorite because they are all that good.
“Melodrama” by Lorde
“Folklore and Evermore” by Taylor Swift
“Five Seconds Flat” by Lizzy McAlpine
This album is pretty new and quickly became one I play on repeat. Every song is great and this album has one of my favorite songs of all time, doomsday. The only thing that brings this down is the tracklist. The greatest song on the album is the first, so no other songs sound as good. When I listen to this album, I usually put it on shuffle.
Harry Styles self-titled album
“Stanger in the Alps” by Phoebe Bridgers
“Midnight Memories” by One Direction
This one may be based solely on nostalgia, but trust me, it’s still just as good as it was when you were in middle school. I recently just listened to this album again, and I forgot how many good songs were on it. “Best Song Ever”, “Story of my Life,” “Diana” and “MIDNIGHT MEMORIES” are amazing. Honestly, how could this album not make the list?
These are just a few of the albums I would personally rank as A-tier. Maybe one day I will discover a perfect album I would confidently put in the S column but until then, take a look at all this great music if you haven’t already.