Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo

I Tried DIY Face Masks for the First Time

This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at VCU chapter.

I have never used a face mask before. But as winter dry skin rolls around and as rubbing certain foods all over your face is becoming increasingly popular, I figured I should give it a try. And if I get flawless skin in the process, even better. I found three popular types of DIY face masks to compare: Coffee, Oatmeal, and Avocado. Here are the results of this experiment, and my thoughts.

Coffee/Cocoa Mask

This mask smelled amazing and looked like chocolate icing. So obviously, because I am a child, I tasted it. Ten out of ten would not recommend (unless you like REALLY strong coffee). After I got past the fact that I looked like I had smeared crap on my face, I enjoyed the process. Because this mask was really cold (due to the yogurt), it felt very soothing. And, as I expected, the coffee was exfoliating, which is always a good thing. About ten minutes in, my face felt really tight which was weird. After I took the mask off, my skin felt very smooth and surprisingly moisturized (due to the honey). I also felt more awake, so maybe I shouldn’t have tried this one at 1 a.m….

Apparently this is the expression I make when I try a face mask for the first time.

Find the mask here

Oatmeal/Banana Mask

I can describe my feelings on this mask in three words: not a fan. While I am sure that oatmeal masks must be popular for a reason, this particular one is not for me. The consistency was completely wrong for a face mask as it was far too thin and, for lack of a better word, too “goopy” for me to get it all on my skin with even coverage and it not completely slide off my face. After a ten minute wrestle with application, the mask was not very soothing other than the fact that it was very cold (due to the milk). When I removed the mask, there was no change except that my skin felt more dehydrated.

Is this a face mask or makeup for The Walking Dead?

Find the instructions here

Avocado Mask

The avocado mask was very refreshing. The yogurt and avocado pairing made it smell clean and fresh. It felt moisturizing and soothing; I can see why this tutorial was called a “winter mask.” The texture was fairly easy to apply thanks to the texture of the yogurt and avocado. However, this mask was a little high maintenance for me as there were more ingredients and steps in this mask than the other two I tried. And it really just made me want guacamole.

On the plus side, the color kind of made me feel like I was about to turn into the Hulk.

Find the mask here

All in all, the coffee mask was my favorite. It was the easiest to make and apply and I felt I got the best results from this mask out of all three. I would definitely try a face mask again, and had fun testing and comparing different ones. 

Katie, a Senior at VCU, is majoring in International Studies focused in European studies and is minoring in both Spanish and Writing. She credits all success and sanity to dry shampoo, The Arctic Monkeys, and chocolate. Her favorite things include argumentative essays, pitbull puppies (or really any puppy), and spring. Katie hopes to one day get paid to travel the world and write.
Keziah is a writer for Her Campus. She is majoring in Fashion Design with a minor in Fashion Merchandising. HCXO!